I grew up believing a Test match could alter the weather inside a house. For five days, meals moved, errands waited and adults argued about fields as though family honour depended on a short leg. I am not naïve enough to demand that every young fan inherit that rhythm. T20 has changed cricket for good, often for the better. But I refuse the BCCI’s comforting fiction that a handsome bonus alone proves the long format is secure. Its Test Cricket Incentive Scheme, announced in 2024, rewards players who take part in a large share of India’s Tests. I welcomed it. I also think it addresses the most visible end of a much deeper problem.
The incentive is sensible—and conveniently easy
The scheme sits on top of the Test match fee and increases rewards according to participation. That sends a useful message to centrally contracted players deciding how much physical and financial value the format carries. Test cricket demands recovery, technical reinvention and weeks away from the commercial spotlight. Paying players more for that burden is reasonable. Anyone who thinks prestige alone will defeat franchise salaries is romantic in the least useful way.
Yet these are already India’s best-paid cricketers. Their decisions matter, but the format’s future depends on hundreds of players who will never receive an international cap. A Test batter does not emerge from a sponsorship deck. He learns to leave outside off stump on a February morning in Hubballi, to bat with the tail in Rajkot, to return for a second spell when the ball has softened and the body has not. The Ranji Trophy is not a heritage display. It is the workshop.
BCCI knows this, which is why domestic cricket reappears in official speeches whenever a star skips it. But scolding individuals is not policy. The board controls the competition, calendar, pitches, travel expectations and financial structure. If domestic first-class cricket is repeatedly squeezed between white-ball events, international tours and the IPL, players receive the real message no matter what administrators say: red-ball preparation is mandatory until a more valuable obligation appears.
A calendar reveals true priorities
I judge institutions by calendars and budgets, not adjectives. BCCI’s published playing-condition library is evidence of the enormous formal structure around each format. The harder question is whether the season allows those rules to produce good cricket. Ranji matches need recovery gaps, travel that does not exhaust teams, and pitches that reward skill rather than manufacture three-day finishes to fit a crowded programme.
India’s geography makes scheduling difficult. Weather windows vary. International commitments are dense. The IPL is commercially indispensable and funds much of the ecosystem. I accept all that. But difficulty cannot become a permanent excuse for treating the first-class season as expandable luggage. When a domestic competition is split or compressed, selectors lose a clean sample, players struggle to build rhythm and supporters cannot follow a coherent championship.
The board should publish a protected red-ball window several years ahead. Not a vague aspiration—a window. Elite players who are fit and not on national duty should appear for their state teams. India A tours should be planned as a bridge rather than an occasional reward. Ground staff should receive incentives for pitches that sustain a fair contest between batting and bowling into the fourth day. None of this produces a glamorous launch video, which is precisely why it would demonstrate seriousness.
Pay the middle, not only the summit
Domestic match fees have improved, and I do not pretend players live in the amateur age. Still, the economic comparison is brutal. A handful of good weeks in a franchise tournament can transform a career; a season of first-class excellence may deliver recognition slowly, if at all. The answer is not to resent the IPL. It is to make a durable domestic career financially respectable even for the player who is excellent but never fashionable.
I would create stronger retainers tied to first-class squads, medical coverage that follows players beyond a season, and pension credits for sustained domestic service. I would reward teams for producing Test-ready cricketers without turning development into a crude points race. I would also invest in broadcast quality. A viewer cannot form an attachment to a competition hidden behind erratic streams, sparse commentary and scorecards that seem designed for relatives.
Some will say audiences simply do not want four-day domestic cricket. That is partly true and partly self-fulfilling. People cannot follow what is badly scheduled, lightly promoted and difficult to watch. The Ranji Trophy will never match IPL ratings, nor must it. Public value is not identical to maximum audience. Academies do not sell as many tickets as finals either, yet no serious sport abandons them.
Test selection must reward Test skills
The format is also weakened when selection becomes seduced by general athletic glamour. White-ball success can reveal nerve and talent, but it does not automatically prove that a batter can manage a moving ball for three hours or a bowler can construct a dismissal across spells. Selectors must keep using domestic red-ball evidence, including India A cricket, even when social media demands the newest franchise star.
That does not mean building walls between formats. The best players adapt, and modern Test cricket has benefited from attacking skills developed in T20. My objection is to treating adaptation as automatic. A ramp shot is not a defence; a two-over burst is not control with an ageing ball. Selection should ask what a player can add to a Test side, not merely whether his name is currently loud.
Workload management requires honesty too. Fast bowlers cannot play everything. Rest is not betrayal. But the system should distinguish planned recovery from format shopping. Central contracts can set expectations, and the incentive scheme is one tool. Transparent communication would help supporters understand why a player is absent instead of leaving every omission to rumour and moral theatre.
What stewardship would look like
BCCI is rich enough to think beyond survival. It can fund day-night domestic experiments where conditions suit them, improve spectator facilities at smaller grounds, support state associations with performance-linked grants and commission independent research on injuries and workloads. It can schedule marquee Ranji games when international players are available. It can make scorecards, archives and video clips easy to find, giving the championship a memory accessible to younger fans.
It should also speak less defensively. Test cricket is not threatened because people are morally shallow. It is threatened because time is scarce, entertainment is abundant and the sport itself has built a commercial product that competes brilliantly for attention. Administrators must design around that reality. A bonus may influence a player; it does not create a season a fan can inhabit.
I am encouraged that BCCI recognised a financial imbalance and acted. The incentive scheme is better than pious speeches about whites and tradition. But I will not confuse a payment to the summit with reinforcement of the mountain. Test cricket’s roots lie in state teams, coaches, curators, scorers and players whose names trend only when a selector finally notices them.
If the board wants me to believe its claim that Tests remain the pinnacle, it should show me the protected calendar, the domestic contracts, the India A programme and the reliable broadcasts. Then the bonus will look like one part of stewardship rather than an expensive shield against criticism. I still believe five days can alter the weather in a house. BCCI’s job is not to share my nostalgia. It is to preserve the conditions in which another generation might discover why the wait is worth it.



