indiancritic
Subscribe

Daayra’s Box-Office Failure Says More About Our Viewing Habits Than Its Adult Certificate

Meghna Gulzar’s procedural was allowed to be morally uncomfortable and visually intact, yet audiences largely stayed away. I think streaming has trained us to praise serious Hindi thrillers in theory while postponing the ticket purchase that keeps them theatrical.

Ishita Banerjee
· 6 min read
Daayra’s Box-Office Failure Says More About Our Viewing Habits Than Its Adult Certificate
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting / GODL-India

Advertisement

I watched Daayra in a theatre with the unsettling luxury of empty seats. Nobody kicked my chair, nobody arrived during the first murder, and nobody illuminated the row while ordering snacks. This would have been pleasant if it had not felt like a diagnosis. Meghna Gulzar’s crime procedural arrived with Kareena Kapoor Khan and Prithviraj Sukumaran, an adult certificate, an uncomfortable argument about police violence and enough star recognition to avoid obscurity. It still struggled to persuade viewers that the proper place to see it was a cinema.

The film’s premise puts two police officers on opposing sides of an investigation into deaths following a horrific crime. Bollywood Hungama’s film page outlines that institutional conflict, while its box-office tracker records a modest theatrical total. I am less interested in treating the number as a verdict on quality than in asking what audience behaviour produced it. Hindi viewers routinely complain that theatres offer only spectacles, sequels and broad comedy. When a star-led adult drama arrives, many of us mentally add it to a future streaming queue.

We have created a genre called “wait for OTT”

“Wait for OTT” sounds like an assessment of scale, but it has become a self-fulfilling distribution category. A quiet film opens; viewers decide it does not require a giant screen; weak advance sales reduce shows; limited showtimes make attendance inconvenient; the disappointing weekend confirms that such films belong online. None of these individual decisions is irrational. Together they train producers to stop making mid-budget theatrical dramas. We then complain that Bollywood no longer trusts adults.

Streaming has altered our sense of urgency. A superhero movie can be spoiled by the internet within hours, so fans rush. A procedural seems patient by definition, and platforms have supplied hundreds of them. Why travel, park, pay and sit with strangers when a similar moral puzzle will appear beside the sofa? The answer has to be more than screen size. Theatrical dramas need event-making built around conversation, performance and atmosphere. Marketing cannot simply cut a trailer like an action film and hope seriousness sells itself.

Daayra also faced a tonal marketing problem. A story involving sexual violence and alleged staged encounters cannot be advertised as cheerful weekend relief. Yet grimness is not a campaign. Viewers need to understand the specific dramatic pleasure: two charismatic actors testing each other, institutions revealing their incentives, certainty collapsing under inquiry. Prestige television markets this experience expertly. Hindi film promotion still often believes the choice is between songs and solemnity. A serious film deserves seduction too.

The adult certificate was honest, not fatal

The CBFC reportedly retained the film’s violent imagery while requiring only a limited dialogue modification; the certification report described no visual cuts. I prefer that clarity to the strange compromise in which a film courts adult themes but sands away their consequences to chase a wider rating. An A certificate reduces the addressable audience, especially for family outings, yet it also tells filmmakers they can speak without pretending every subject is suitable for children.

Blaming certification alone is too easy. Adult-rated international films find Indian audiences when marketed as must-see experiences. The larger issue is that Hindi cinema has weakened the habit of attending adult dramas. Multiplex pricing encourages customers to save expensive outings for spectacle. Show allocation rewards opening velocity. Serious films are expected to grow by word of mouth but may lose screens before that mouth finishes a sentence. Exhibitors and producers need flexible pricing and patient scheduling if they genuinely want variety.

Kareena’s casting matters because she brings the residue of glamour into a role the film refuses to reduce to glamorous toughness. I am tired of the “strong female cop” written as a male action hero with better eyeliner. Authority can appear through attention, discipline and the willingness to doubt colleagues. A mature star is particularly useful because the audience reads history on her face. Hindi cinema should be building more parts around actresses whose fame has outlived the industry’s old marriage-and-age expiry dates.

Prithviraj’s presence performs a different function. He arrives with authority from Malayalam cinema and a multilingual career, allowing the film to complicate the familiar North Indian cop archetype. Pan-Indian casting is usually sold as a market-expansion spreadsheet: put actors from several industries on a poster and call the project national. Here the value is artistic. Different performance traditions rub against each other. I would like more cross-industry casting motivated by character rather than a producer’s desire for four dubbed opening weekends.

Streaming will rescue the film—and reinforce the problem

Daayra is almost designed for a streaming afterlife. Viewers will pause, search the real-world context, argue about procedure and recommend it in messages. The same people who skipped the theatre may praise the film once a subscription absorbs the apparent price. That second life is valuable. Streaming can rescue work from the brutality of opening weekend and carry it across languages. But every rescue teaches financiers that the theatre was the wrong first destination.

I do not believe every serious film must open theatrically. Some stories benefit from episodic space or intimate viewing. Distribution should follow form and economics. My objection is to the casual assumption that adult drama inherently lacks theatrical value. A concentrated room changes how we experience moral pressure. Silence becomes collective; discomfort cannot be escaped by checking a phone; the faces of actors acquire scale. Daayra’s confrontations gained from that attention, even in my nearly empty auditorium.

The industry could build a different model: lower ticket prices during the first week for selected mid-budget films, post-screening conversations, targeted university and professional-group outreach, subtitled nationwide releases from day one, and minimum two-week show commitments in major cities. None guarantees success. They merely give word of mouth time to exist. At present, a film is often declared rejected before the intended audience learns that it opened.

Audiences are not obligated to support cinema as homework. If a film looks joyless, repetitive or exploitative, people may reasonably stay home. Filmmakers must earn attention. Daayra is not beyond criticism; its procedural machinery can feel overdetermined, and solemnity occasionally substitutes for ambiguity. Yet I would rather argue about those flaws after viewing than use empty seats as proof that the attempt was misguided. Commercial failure and creative failure overlap less neatly than trade discourse suggests.

What strikes me most is the gap between our declared taste and our purchased taste. Online, we demand mature writing, substantial roles for women and stars who take risks. At the ticket counter, we often select recognisable spectacle and reserve maturity for a Tuesday night stream. Producers watch behaviour, not manifestos. If we want a theatrical culture broader than universes and opening-weekend noise, some of us will have to buy tickets for films that do not promise explosions every fifteen minutes.

Daayra’s streaming life may eventually dwarf its cinema run, and I will be glad if viewers find it. I will also remember that empty room. It represented no conspiracy against serious cinema, only thousands of ordinary calculations that added up to abandonment. The future of adult Hindi drama will be decided by those calculations: pricing, convenience, marketing, patience and the audience’s willingness to leave the sofa. We cannot stream our way into a diverse theatrical culture while waiting for somebody else to attend it.

#daayra #kareena-kapoor #streaming #box-office
Ishita Banerjee

Written by

Watches everything — Bollywood, Hollywood, the whole streaming pile — and writes about what it actually says about us.

More by Ishita →

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Entertainment

View all →