Every electric-car presentation in India contains the same reassuring map: dots spread across cities and highways until range anxiety appears statistically impossible. Then an owner arrives at one of those dots and finds a locked gate, a dead charger, a connector occupied by a parked combustion car or an app demanding registration in weak mobile coverage. This gap between mapped infrastructure and dependable infrastructure is the EV transition’s least photogenic problem.
The government’s PM E-DRIVE charging announcement described a ₹2,000-crore push and an ambition for tens of thousands of public chargers across key cities, highways and transport hubs. Scale is welcome. I would now like policy to stop rewarding mere installation and start rewarding successful charging sessions.
Availability must mean operational availability
A fuel station is useful because motorists broadly know what awaits them: a visible forecourt, staff, standard fuel, rapid payment and a transaction measured in minutes. EV charging is more fragmented. Operators use different apps, connectors, power ratings and price structures. A station may appear online while being offline in practice. A slow charger can be technically functional yet useless to a driver expecting a highway stop.
India needs a public definition of uptime measured at connector level. Operators receiving subsidy should publish real-time status, successful-session rates and repair response times through an open interface. A charger that is energised but repeatedly fails authentication should count as unavailable. So should one blocked by poor site management.
Capital subsidy without maintenance obligations encourages ribbon-cutting. The operator receives help to install hardware; the driver later discovers nobody has a strong incentive to keep it reliable. Public support should be released in stages, with a portion tied to uptime and utilisation over several years.
Location quality beats dot quantity
Not all chargers serve the same need. Apartment residents require dependable neighbourhood charging because they may lack assigned parking. Fleet vehicles need high utilisation and predictable turnaround. Highway drivers need fast chargers near clean toilets, food, lighting and safe waiting areas. Buses and trucks require entirely different power and space planning.
A charger placed where electricity connection was convenient may be a poor mobility asset. Government and operators should use traffic data, vehicle registrations, typical dwell time and gaps between existing sites. Redundancy matters. A highway location with one connector is a single point of failure; two competing sites nearby create resilience.
Oil-marketing companies have an advantage because fuel stations already offer visible, staffed locations and familiar access. But simply placing a charger in a corner is not integration. Staff must know basic troubleshooting, parking must be enforced, and the electrical capacity must deliver the advertised speed when multiple vehicles connect.
The showroom omits the apartment problem
Salespeople discuss range, regenerative braking and home chargers as if every buyer owns a driveway. Indian cities are full of rented flats, informal parking, housing societies and shared electrical infrastructure. Permission for a dedicated connection can become more difficult than choosing the car. Older buildings may require upgrades, and residents worry about fire, billing and ownership of common space.
Policy should create model housing-society rules: transparent permission processes, licensed installation standards, separate metering and cost sharing for upstream upgrades. Fire services and electricity distribution companies need clear guidance. Bans imposed through vague fear are not acceptable, but neither is careless wiring.
Workplace charging can fill part of the gap because cars sit for hours. Slower chargers there may be more useful than expensive fast equipment elsewhere. Municipal parking and shopping centres can do the same. The objective is not to make every charger fast; it is to match power to dwell time.
Payment should be boring
I do not want six charging apps, six wallets and six minimum balances. UPI has taught Indian consumers that interoperable payment can be simple. Every public charger should permit a guest session through a QR code or card without forcing an account. Prices should be displayed before charging, including energy, time, parking and taxes.
A unified discovery layer would help, but a government super-app should not become another monopoly interface. Open standards are better. Let navigation apps, car dashboards and operator apps access the same live status and tariff data. Drivers should be able to reserve only where reservation can be enforced, with penalties for both no-shows and operators that fail to deliver.
Receipts should show energy delivered, charging duration and total price. Dispute resolution must be reachable. A failed session that temporarily blocks a large card amount can ruin confidence faster than any advertisement repairs it.
Grid arguments require nuance
Critics say India’s coal-heavy electricity makes EVs pointless. Advocates sometimes respond as if every electron is already solar. Both positions are lazy. EV emissions depend on the grid, vehicle efficiency, manufacturing and use. They can improve as the grid becomes cleaner, and they shift pollution away from dense street-level combustion. That does not erase battery impacts or power-sector emissions.
Charging policy can improve the equation by encouraging daytime workplace charging where solar output is available, managed charging during low-demand periods and storage at constrained sites. Tariffs should discourage every vehicle from demanding maximum power at the evening peak. Smart charging is less glamorous than a new model launch but may save expensive grid upgrades.
Distribution companies must be involved early. A cluster of fast chargers can create significant local load even when citywide electricity supply is adequate. Transformer capacity, land and connection timelines shape deployment. Announcing chargers before upstream power is ready produces stranded hardware.
Trust will sell more EVs than subsidies alone
Purchase incentives reduce upfront cost, but infrastructure trust changes behaviour. An owner who confidently completes intercity trips becomes a better ambassador than a celebrity campaign. Conversely, one failed family journey generates a story repeated for years. Early adopters tolerate friction; mainstream buyers do not owe the industry patience.
Automakers should share responsibility. They can integrate reliable charger data, negotiate roaming, provide route planning that accounts for elevation and weather, and support owners when third-party charging fails. Selling the car and pointing at someone else’s app is not enough.
The government should publish a national dashboard listing subsidised sites, connector types, commissioning dates, uptime, utilisation and unresolved faults. Independent audits can verify a sample. Remove support from persistently failed operators. Infrastructure policy becomes credible when failure has consequences.
I am bullish on Indian EVs where the use case fits: urban commuters with home charging, fleets with depot charging and households whose second car covers predictable routes. I am cautious about telling every buyer that the transition is frictionless. Honesty will not kill adoption. It will prevent disappointment.
A charger is not infrastructure merely because concrete was poured and a machine was photographed. Infrastructure is a service citizens can depend on at night, in rain, with children in the car and fifteen per cent battery remaining. Count successful sessions, not metal boxes. When that becomes the metric, the dots on the showroom map may finally deserve our trust.
