indiancritic
Subscribe

Bhilar’s Houses Became Libraries—and Made Our Smart-City Obsession Look Silly

The Maharashtra village’s modest reading network succeeded because residents became custodians. Its lesson is that culture grows through shared ownership, not expensive civic hardware.

Devansh Kapoor
· 4 min read
Bhilar’s Houses Became Libraries—and Made Our Smart-City Obsession Look Silly
AvyaktaShashi / CC BY-SA 4.0

Advertisement

India likes civic projects with plaques, consultants and renderings of citizens who appear never to sweat. Bhilar, a village near Panchgani, did something less sophisticated and therefore more interesting: it put books in homes, schools, temples and businesses, then invited people to read. Residents became librarians without acquiring lanyards or inventing an app. The result has lasted long enough to embarrass many expensive urban initiatives launched with greater amplification.

The Indian Express account of Bhilar’s 2017 launch described about 25 reading premises and villagers taking responsibility for collections. A later report on expanding the model said the original village held more than 15,000 books and had attracted a steady stream of visitors. The charming part is not the quantity. It is the breach of a familiar boundary: private rooms became pieces of public culture.

A library does not require monumental architecture

Urban India tends to imagine a library as a building, and then to explain why land, staff and maintenance make the building impossible. Bhilar distributed the institution across spaces that already existed. A visitor walks from one collection to another, and the village itself becomes the reading room.

This has limits. Books need cataloguing, preservation and trained selection. A scattered network cannot replace research libraries or well-funded public branches. But it can answer a simpler question: how do we place readable books near people without waiting for a perfect capital project?

Unused rooms in panchayat buildings, railway stations, clinics and housing societies could host small collections. The scarce resource is not always floor area. It is stewardship. A locked cupboard of donated textbooks is not a library.

The resident-librarian is the real infrastructure

Bhilar works because households do more than tolerate shelves. They welcome strangers, guide readers and make the collection part of daily life. That social labour is easy to romanticise and easy to exploit. Expansion must compensate coordinators, fund replacement and avoid turning residents into unpaid props for tourists.

Still, ownership creates resilience that a contractor cannot. When a project belongs to nobody after inauguration, dust is the most committed user. A resident who knows which child likes comics and which visitor wants poetry supplies the human recommendation engine technology companies keep trying to simulate.

The model also gives older residents and local businesses a cultural role. A homestay with biographies or a house with children’s literature becomes a destination. Reading is attached to hospitality rather than school discipline.

Tourism can help and spoil it

Bhilar’s location between well-known hill stations makes literary tourism plausible. Visitors can read, buy local produce and stay overnight. That brings income and gives the project an economic constituency.

But success can transform a reading village into a backdrop for photographs of people pretending to read. Cafés may crowd out quiet spaces; rents may rise; collections may be selected for tourists rather than residents. The village should measure whether local children and adults use the books, not merely how many cars arrive on weekends.

Replication is another danger. Officials adore a template. Paint walls, purchase books, nominate homes, conduct inauguration. The missing ingredient is consent. A village without willing custodians will produce decorative shelves and excellent inspection photographs.

What cities should steal

Housing societies could adopt subject collections distributed among willing homes or common rooms. Municipalities could support neighbourhood librarians with small grants and a shared catalogue. Schools could open selected libraries after hours through local partnerships. None requires facial recognition or a command centre.

Publishers can donate intelligently, but donation drives must stop treating libraries as disposal sites for unwanted exam guides. A collection needs current children’s books, fiction, local history and material in languages residents read. Ten chosen books can be more useful than a hundred kilograms of moral obligation.

Digital tools can help catalogue and circulate without becoming the project’s centre. The test is whether someone can borrow a book when a phone battery is dead. If not, we have rebuilt an online store with worse stock.

A pleasantly small idea

I do not want to burden Bhilar with saving Indian reading. Literacy, publishing, school quality and household leisure are much larger questions. Nor should every village become a themed tourist attraction.

Its achievement is more modest and more durable. It shows that public culture can be assembled from trust, rooms and people who care for objects together. That sounds obvious. Our development bureaucracy often spends enormous sums avoiding obvious things.

Bhilar’s shelves will not impress a smart-city dashboard. They do something better: they invite a stranger to sit down. In a country skilled at building gates, that is a civic technology worth copying.

#bhilar #libraries #maharashtra #reading
Devansh Kapoor

Written by

Finds the story everyone else's newsroom scrolled past. Dry, a little merciless, always looking for what's actually going on underneath.

More by Devansh →

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Offbeat

View all →