indiancritic
Subscribe

India Does Not Need a Charger on Every Corner; It Needs Chargers That Work Where People Wait

The charging network’s low utilisation is not proof that EV infrastructure has failed. It is evidence that operators, cities and carmakers have chased pin counts while neglecting reliability, apartment charging and locations that fit real journeys.

Ritika Menon
· 6 min read
India Does Not Need a Charger on Every Corner; It Needs Chargers That Work Where People Wait

Advertisement

Showroom conversations about electric cars follow a comforting script. The salesperson points to a range number, opens an app full of charger icons and explains that the network is expanding rapidly. Nobody asks whether the charger behind the icon is powered, accessible, compatible, occupied by a petrol car or located inside a hotel that expects you to buy dinner. India’s charging problem is no longer simply a shortage of dots on a map. It is a shortage of dependable charging woven into places where drivers already park.

Autocar India reported rapid network expansion alongside public-charger utilisation as low as one to five percent. Separately, the early performance of Japanese electric scooters shows how hesitant established manufacturers remain: reported sales for Honda, Suzuki and Yamaha formed only a tiny share of the electric two-wheeler market. These facts do not tell me Indians reject EVs. They tell me infrastructure and products are still being deployed around corporate milestones rather than ownership routines.

Low utilisation is a map-design problem

A charger can be underused for several reasons. It may sit in the wrong location, charge too slowly, remain unreliable or serve drivers who mostly charge at home. Operators need utilisation to recover costs, but placing chargers only where land is easy produces a network nobody needs. A highway charger beside clean toilets and food may be valuable even with uneven daily demand because it enables intercity travel. A city fast charger hidden in a basement with confusing access may be economically useless despite nearby EVs.

We should separate three networks. Destination charging belongs at offices, malls, hotels and public parking where vehicles remain for hours. Highway fast charging needs redundancy, high power and twenty-four-hour amenities. Residential charging requires slow, affordable access where cars and scooters sleep. Policy often treats these as interchangeable “charging stations.” They are different services with different land, power and business requirements. Counting all connectors together produces an impressive number and a poor plan.

Reliability data must become public. Every operator should report uptime, successful session rate, average repair time, power delivered and pricing in a standard format. Apps should show live status based on the charger, not a user’s hopeful report from last Tuesday. A driver arriving at a dead charger with ten percent battery does not care how many total stations the ministry inaugurated. Reliability is range. Redundant connectors at important sites are more useful than isolated ceremonial installations.

Apartment charging is the real urban battle

Most EV marketing quietly assumes a private parking bay and cooperative electrical connection. Indian cities contain millions of residents in apartments, rented homes and informal parking arrangements. Housing societies worry about fire, billing, cable routes and unequal use of common power. Some concerns are reasonable; others become excuses for obstruction. Without a clear right-to-charge framework, the EV transition risks becoming a privilege for bungalow owners and premium new developments.

States need model rules that let residents install certified chargers at their own cost when technically feasible, with transparent load assessment and metering. Distribution companies should offer standard application processes and publish upgrade charges. Housing societies should not be allowed to impose arbitrary bans, but neither should owners run extension cables through stairwells. Fire services, electrical inspectors, carmakers and resident associations need one practical code rather than contradictory pamphlets.

Shared slow chargers may solve more problems than rows of expensive fast units. Cars remain parked overnight, so modest power is usually sufficient. Smart load management can distribute available capacity across vehicles and delay charging away from peak demand. The glamour lies in a charger promising hundreds of kilometres in minutes; the useful infrastructure may be a quiet socket delivering energy over seven hours. Policy should subsidise safe wiring and load management before subsidising decorative hardware.

Two-wheelers require a different approach. Removable batteries can help renters but create weight, safety and standardisation challenges. Fixed-battery scooters work beautifully for owners with ground-level parking and terribly for somebody on the fifth floor without a socket. Battery swapping suits high-utilisation fleets when standards and economics align, not necessarily every private rider. Manufacturers must stop presenting one architecture as universal. India’s parking diversity is as important as its road diversity.

Carmakers must own part of the experience

Automakers like selling the car and outsourcing anxiety to charging companies. That separation is unacceptable during an early transition. If a brand advertises a network in its sales pitch, it should integrate payments, display reliable status, provide customer support and help when a station fails. Plug-and-charge interoperability should be the goal. Drivers should not need six apps, six wallets and six minimum balances to purchase electricity. We solved roaming in telecom; we can solve it for cars.

Dealers also need to conduct honest charging audits before delivery. Where will the buyer charge? Who owns the parking? What sanctioned load exists? How frequently does the car travel beyond the city? A salesperson worried about closing the month may wave these questions away. The result is a frustrated owner blaming the technology for a foreseeable mismatch. I would rather lose an EV sale today than create an anti-EV evangelist for five years.

Pricing must be transparent and comprehensible. Operators may charge per unit of energy, time, parking or session, sometimes in combination. Idle fees are reasonable at busy fast chargers, but customers need clear warnings. Taxes and parking charges can turn a cheap-energy promise into a surprise bill. Standard display rules—energy price, estimated session cost and penalty terms—would let drivers compare services. Petrol pumps show price before fuelling; electrons should not require contract law.

The grid argument is often exaggerated in both directions. EVs will not automatically collapse India’s grid, nor are they free of system consequences. Concentrated evening charging can worsen local peaks, while managed charging can absorb renewable energy and improve asset use. Distribution-level planning matters more than national slogans. Utilities need visibility into charger loads and incentives for off-peak use. Vehicle-to-grid experiments are interesting, but reliable basic connections should come before futuristic press releases.

A fair counterargument says low public utilisation is expected because most charging occurs at home. Correct—and that is why raw utilisation should not be used to declare the network a failure. Some infrastructure has option value: drivers buy an EV because a highway corridor is covered even if they use those chargers rarely. But option value does not excuse poor siting or perpetual subsidy. Strategic stations may deserve support; ordinary commercial stations must eventually attract enough sessions to maintain themselves.

India’s EV transition will be won through boring competence. Put reliable fast chargers on major corridors with toilets, shade and multiple working guns. Put slow chargers in apartments and workplaces. Publish uptime. Standardise payments. Train technicians. Make dealers examine a buyer’s parking reality. Penalise operators that collect incentives for dead equipment. None of this photographs as well as a minister plugging in a new car, but it determines whether families recommend the technology to neighbours.

I remain optimistic because electric vehicles already work extremely well for the right Indian use cases. Quiet urban driving, low routine energy cost and home charging are persuasive once experienced. The infrastructure gap is not an argument to halt transition; it is an instruction to design it around people rather than counts. We do not need a charger on every corner. We need the charger at the apartment, office or highway stop where a vehicle waits—and we need it to work the first time.

#ev-charging #electric-cars #infrastructure #apartments
Ritika Menon

Written by

Covers India's EV transition and the infrastructure gap nobody in a showroom will mention — charging, range claims, and who's actually buying.

More by Ritika →

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Automobiles

View all →