indiancritic
Subscribe

Make in India Has Won the Assembly Battle; It Has Not Yet Won the Indian Brand Battle

India’s electronics incentives have built real manufacturing scale, and dismissing that as mere screwdriver work is lazy. But Chinese brands still dominate consumer mindshare because factories alone do not create design, software, distribution or trust.

Priya Nair
· 6 min read
Make in India Has Won the Assembly Battle; It Has Not Yet Won the Indian Brand Battle
Wikideas1 / CC0

Advertisement

Indian electronics policy attracts two equally unserious reactions. Government cheerleaders point to rising production and declare self-reliance complete. Cynics see imported components entering an Indian factory and sneer “assembly” as though industrial capability arrives fully formed on day one. I reject both. The production-linked incentive programme has helped India build meaningful mobile-manufacturing scale, attract global supply chains and expand exports. The official MeitY scheme page states the design plainly: incentives on incremental sales for mobile phones and specified components. That is real policy. It is not yet the same thing as Indian technological leadership.

Assembly is a stage, not an insult

Every manufacturing ecosystem begins by doing some tasks before others. Assembly teaches quality control, logistics, supplier coordination, yield management and delivery at scale. Workers and managers acquire knowledge that cannot be downloaded from a policy note. Factories create demand for packaging, tooling, testing and maintenance. The correct question is not whether India begins with assembly. It is whether value addition deepens over time.

The government deserves credit for moving beyond speeches. The official list of approved companies includes major contract manufacturers, Samsung and Indian firms. Bringing those networks into India reduces the gap between political aspiration and industrial practice. Apple’s supplier expansion in India, in particular, demonstrates that global firms will diversify production when policy, labour and infrastructure align.

But incentive success should be measured against the counterfactual and the next stage. How much production would have moved from China anyway because firms wanted geographic diversification? How much domestic value is created after imported displays, memory, processors and camera modules are counted? Are incentives producing durable capability or activity that will migrate when payments end? Government should publish answers in comparable annual tables.

Why Chinese brands still understand the buyer

Walk into an Indian phone shop and the power of Chinese brands becomes obvious. Xiaomi, Vivo, Oppo, Realme, OnePlus and their rivals built distribution, service relationships and product ladders tailored to Indian price bands. They learned that a buyer may care about battery life, camera processing, storage and financing in a different order than a reviewer. They supplied models at relentless speed and made retailers care about selling them.

“Chinese dominance” is not one simple phenomenon. Brands may manufacture devices in India, employ Indian workers and source some local inputs while design, intellectual property and strategic control remain abroad. Policy debate becomes confused when it treats the nationality of the logo, location of final assembly and origin of value as identical. They are not.

Indian brands lost ground for reasons beyond unfair competition. Too many relied on rebadged designs, inconsistent software and weak after-sales support. National sentiment can open a browser tab; it cannot make a bad phone good for two years. Consumers spending carefully earned money are not obliged to subsidise corporate learning through unreliable products. Patriotism is not a warranty.

The missing layers are difficult

India needs component ecosystems, industrial design, radio engineering, operating-system expertise, camera tuning, update teams and global procurement strength. Semiconductor fabrication receives the headlines, but less glamorous capabilities matter too: connectors, enclosures, batteries, power electronics, printed circuit boards and testing equipment. A resilient phone industry is a web, not one giant factory photograph.

Domestic value addition should be reported with a clear method. Companies and ministries often cite production values that count the full phone, even when high-value parts are imported. That number is useful for scale but not sufficient for depth. Publish gross output, exports, imported-input share, local component categories, employment quality and incentive paid. Let success withstand measurement.

Research and development incentives may be needed, but they should reward actual Indian engineering and owned intellectual property rather than the relabelling of routine localisation. Government procurement can create demand for secure Indian devices in defined uses, yet it must not become a refuge for products citizens would reject. Standards should be stricter when taxpayers are the buyer.

Support an Indian brand without protecting mediocrity

The new policy ambition to support Indian mobile brands is understandable. Scale in contract manufacturing does not automatically produce a company that owns the customer relationship. A national ecosystem benefits from firms making product decisions, holding patents and building global brands from India. But officials cannot select a champion by press conference.

Support should be competitive and conditional. Require update commitments, service coverage, security disclosure and measurable domestic engineering. Release incentives against audited outcomes. Encourage several firms rather than constructing one politically favoured survivor. Failure must remain possible; otherwise public money preserves weak management.

Indian brands should begin with segments where they can solve local problems better. Rugged enterprise devices, secure government handsets, repairable education tablets or phones optimised for long service in difficult climates may offer more credible entry than another generic glass slab advertised through nationalism. Design advantage grows from knowing a user, not copying the market leader six months later.

Chinese firms are competitors and part of the ecosystem

Policy must manage security, taxation and legal compliance firmly. No foreign company deserves exemption from Indian law because it sells popular phones. At the same time, treating every Chinese-linked manufacturer solely as an enemy ignores jobs, supplier learning and consumer welfare. India’s objective should be to capture more value and reduce strategic vulnerability without casually destroying the market that sustains factories.

Clear rules are more effective than unpredictable hostility. Firms should know data, investment, localisation and compliance expectations. Enforcement should be evidence-based and consistent. Sudden uncertainty increases costs for Indian suppliers and workers as well as foreign shareholders.

The long-term competitive answer is capability. If Indian firms design desirable phones, provide five years of updates, repair them quickly and price them well, consumers will buy them. If they do not, a flag on the box will not rescue them. Chinese brands became formidable through iteration, supply-chain leverage and retail execution. India should study that discipline rather than imagine slogans defeated it.

Celebrate the factory, then ask what comes next

I am optimistic because industrial clusters can compound. Once volumes rise, suppliers have a reason to locate nearby. Once suppliers arrive, local engineering becomes more economical. Exports expose factories to hard quality requirements. Skilled workers move between firms and carry knowledge. PLI helped push that wheel, and critics who deny any achievement are arguing with visible investment.

My optimism is conditional because incentive programmes are skilled at producing flattering totals. The government should be candid about import dependence and set staged goals for components, design and research. It should invest in ports, power reliability, vocational training and urban services around manufacturing clusters. A production subsidy cannot compensate forever for expensive logistics or poor worker housing.

Make in India has won an important first battle: India is now a serious location for making phones at scale. The next battles are harder because they involve knowledge, ownership and trust. We need Indian engineers making more decisions, Indian suppliers capturing more value and Indian brands earning purchases without emotional blackmail.

I will applaud each factory line. I will also look behind the final screw to ask who designed the board, owns the software, controls the patents and receives the profit. That is not pessimism. It is how an assembly success becomes an electronics power rather than a temporary stop in somebody else’s supply chain.

#make in india #smartphones #pli scheme #electronics manufacturing
Priya Nair

Written by

Tracks what 'Make in India' electronics policy actually delivers versus what it promises, and why Chinese brands still eat everyone's lunch here.

More by Priya →

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Technology

View all →