indiancritic
Subscribe

India’s New Mobile Manufacturing Push Must Graduate From Assembly Arithmetic

I welcome the scale created by electronics incentives, but domestic value cannot be measured by counting finished phones alone. The next policy phase must reward components, tooling, design and Indian suppliers that survive without permanent protection.

Priya Nair
· 4 min read
India’s New Mobile Manufacturing Push Must Graduate From Assembly Arithmetic
CWB Metal / CC BY 4.0

Advertisement

India has earned the right to claim progress in mobile manufacturing. Factories are producing at scale, exports have risen and global brands now treat the country as a serious production base. I do not share the fashionable view that assembly is meaningless. Every industrial chain begins somewhere, and workers, logistics firms and suppliers learn by doing.

But the government’s next mobile manufacturing scheme raises a harder question: what exactly are we building beneath the final product? A Press Information Bureau release archive records the government’s electronics-policy announcements, while the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology maintains the official production-linked incentive material. Ambitious output targets are useful. They are not a substitute for measuring domestic value.

Assembly is a beginning, not an insult

Critics often say Indian plants merely screw together imported parts. The word “merely” does too much work. High-volume electronics assembly requires quality control, process discipline, supplier coordination and delivery reliability. These capabilities can spill into other manufacturing.

The government deserves credit for using incentives and tariffs to create a scale that laissez-faire nostalgia would not have produced. India was not going to wake up one morning with a complete electronics ecosystem because a columnist wished for comparative advantage.

Yet assembly can become a comfortable plateau. If high-value components, manufacturing equipment, firmware expertise and product design remain external, production numbers exaggerate resilience. A phone can carry a “made in India” label while much of its economic intelligence arrives in crates and licensing agreements.

Chinese brands still understand the Indian market

Chinese smartphone companies remain powerful here because they built fast distribution, aggressive pricing and products calibrated to Indian buyers. They know the importance of large batteries, quick charging, retail margins and eye-catching specifications at precise price points. Political discomfort has not erased commercial competence.

Indian brands cannot defeat that advantage through flags printed on packaging. They need control over product road maps, after-sales service and supply relationships. A rebadged catalogue phone promoted as national revival will be detected by buyers who compare everything on YouTube before entering a shop.

The government should therefore distinguish Indian ownership from Indian capability. Both can matter, but neither should be assumed from the other. A foreign company building deep supplier networks in India may create more durable value than a locally owned brand importing a nearly complete device.

Incentives need sharper conditions

The next scheme should reward verified increases in local value: enclosures, printed circuit board assembly, camera modules, batteries, chargers, connectors, tooling and eventually more sophisticated semiconductor work. Targets should recognise that these layers differ in difficulty. Counting every component equally would invite creative paperwork.

Supplier development matters as much as headline factories. Small and medium firms need testing infrastructure, patient credit and predictable standards. Large contract manufacturers can meet output targets while importing from established Asian networks; developing local vendors is slower and riskier. Policy must make that investment rational.

I would also publish company-level outcomes after protecting legitimate commercial secrets. How much subsidy was disbursed? What production and export thresholds were met? How did local value change? How many suppliers entered the chain? Without this information, policy debate degenerates into government celebration versus opposition cynicism.

Tariffs cannot do the whole job

Import duties can encourage localisation, but badly calibrated duties raise prices and make exports less competitive. Components unavailable at the required quality should not be taxed simply to create an impressive wall. Protection must be time-bound, reviewed and connected to capability milestones.

Congress and the left often criticise incentives as corporate gifts while simultaneously demanding manufacturing jobs. That contradiction is tiresome. Industrial policy necessarily works through firms. The responsible question is whether public support purchases measurable learning, investment and competition.

The government’s weakness has sometimes been its fondness for aggregate triumph. Production value is announced; the composition receives less attention. I want ministers to boast about Indian toolmakers, battery suppliers and design teams with the same enthusiasm they reserve for shipment numbers.

India has moved beyond being ignored in electronics manufacturing. The danger now is mistaking entry into the race for victory. Assembly created the platform. The next policy must make it harder, deeper and more Indian—not through rhetoric, but through suppliers whose names most consumers will never see.

#make-in-india #mobile-manufacturing #electronics #supply-chain
Priya Nair

Written by

Tracks what 'Make in India' electronics policy actually delivers versus what it promises, and why Chinese brands still eat everyone's lunch here.

More by Priya →

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Technology

View all →