indiancritic
Subscribe
Meenakshi Iyer
Indian Politics

Meenakshi Iyer.

Tired of Lutyens Delhi's chosen narratives. Calls out manufactured outrage from the INDIA alliance and the commentariat that amplifies it for what it is.

Articles by Meenakshi

17 articles
Delimitation Needs a Formula, Not the INDIA Bloc’s Panic Button

· 7 min read

Delimitation Needs a Formula, Not the INDIA Bloc’s Panic Button

Southern states have a legitimate concern about representation after the next census. Turning that concern into an accusation that the government plans to punish them is premature theatre; the serious task is designing a settlement that respects both population and federal trust.

The Opposition’s Electoral-Roll Theatre Cannot Replace Evidence

· 6 min read

The Opposition’s Electoral-Roll Theatre Cannot Replace Evidence

Voter lists must be transparent, appealable and carefully audited, but the INDIA alliance weakens that cause when it treats every correction exercise as proof of a conspiracy. I want a tougher Election Commission and a more responsible opposition, not slogans that declare the verdict before the evidence arrives.

Delimitation Needed Persuasion; the Opposition Supplied Only Panic

· 6 min read

Delimitation Needed Persuasion; the Opposition Supplied Only Panic

The failed delimitation push exposed legitimate federal anxieties, but the INDIA alliance preferred slogans about southern punishment to the harder work of designing equal representation. The government should return with stronger safeguards, not abandon the principle.

Delimitation Needs a Negotiation, Not the INDIA Bloc’s Rehearsed Panic

· 7 min read

Delimitation Needs a Negotiation, Not the INDIA Bloc’s Rehearsed Panic

Southern states have a legitimate question about representation after the next census. Turning that question into a pre-emptive accusation that the Centre intends to punish them is politically convenient, constitutionally premature and corrosive to the federal bargain.

The Outrage Factory Cannot Substitute for an Electoral Argument

· 6 min read

The Outrage Factory Cannot Substitute for an Electoral Argument

The INDIA alliance’s habit of treating every institutional reform as an assault on democracy is exhausting—and strategically foolish. On simultaneous elections, it should debate the safeguards instead of manufacturing a constitutional apocalypse.

The Opposition’s SIR Panic Is Not a Substitute for an Argument About Clean Voter Rolls

· 7 min read

The Opposition’s SIR Panic Is Not a Substitute for an Argument About Clean Voter Rolls

The Election Commission’s roll revision deserves scrutiny and humane implementation, but the INDIA alliance’s reflexive cry of disenfranchisement treats every verification exercise as a conspiracy. I think the government’s side should defend cleaner rolls while insisting that no genuine voter be defeated by paperwork.

Also in Indian Politics

View all →